Ruby vs Garnet: How to Tell Them Apart and Which to Buy
Ruby and garnet are both red but differ in hardness, colour and price. Learn how to tell them apart and which suits your ring.
·
6 minute read
Ruby and garnet are both red, both set in men’s rings, and for centuries they were confused with each other. They are very different stones. One is among the most valuable gems in the world, and the other is one of the most affordable. Knowing which is which protects you from paying a ruby price for a garnet, and helps you choose the right one on purpose.
The short answer
Ruby is harder. It scores 9 on the Mohs scale. Garnet scores 6.5 to 7.5.
Ruby is brighter. Its red is purer and often has a glow. Garnet is darker, leaning to wine red or brown.
Ruby costs far more. A natural ruby can cost many times the price of a garnet of the same size.
Garnet is usually cleaner. Natural rubies show small internal marks. Garnets are often clear to the eye.
Both are good ring stones. Choose ruby for rarity and daily toughness, garnet for rich colour at a modest price.
Ruby and garnet compared
Ruby
Garnet
Hardness
9
6.5–7.5
Colour
Pure, bright red
Dark, wine red
Clarity
Small marks
Often clean
Price
High
Low
Birth month
July
January
How they differ
What they are
Ruby is the red variety of the mineral corundum, the same mineral as sapphire. Its colour comes from chromium. Garnet is a family of related minerals. The red garnets used in jewellery are mostly pyrope, almandine and rhodolite, coloured mainly by iron.
Colour
This is the difference you can see. A good ruby is a strong red, sometimes with a slight pink or blue tint, and it seems to glow from inside. Garnet is deeper and more subdued, often with a brown or purple cast, like red wine in a glass. In dim light a garnet can look almost black, while a ruby stays red.
Hardness and wear
Ruby is second only to diamond in hardness and resists the fine scratching that dulls softer stones. Garnet is hard enough for a ring, but after years of daily wear its surface picks up small scratches and its facet edges soften. A jeweller can polish it back.
Clarity
Natural rubies almost always contain small inclusions. Garnets, particularly the darker ones, are frequently clean to the naked eye. A large, perfectly clean, dark red stone at a low price is more likely garnet than ruby.
Price
The gap is wide. Fine ruby is one of the most expensive coloured stones per carat. Red garnet is plentiful and costs a small fraction as much. That makes garnet an honest, attractive choice, and it also makes it the most common stone passed off as ruby.
How to tell them apart
Compare the colour in daylight
Take the stone to a window. Ruby holds a bright red in daylight. Garnet turns darker and browner. If you can place the stone beside a known ruby or garnet, the difference is usually obvious.
Use an ultraviolet torch
Many rubies glow red under a small ultraviolet torch, because of the chromium in them. Garnet does not glow at all. This test is useful but not final: some rubies glow only weakly, and lab-created rubies glow strongly too.
Look inside with a magnifier
Under a 10x loupe, fine needles and fingerprint-like patterns suggest ruby. A stone with very little inside it, in a dark red, suggests garnet.
Ask a jeweller
A jeweller can separate the two in seconds. Ruby bends light in two directions and shows two slightly different shades of red when viewed through a simple instrument. Garnet shows only one. If the price is significant, this quick check is worth asking for.
Why the two were confused for so long
Before modern gem testing, red stones were sorted by colour alone. Ruby, garnet and red spinel were all traded under the same names, and the old word carbuncle covered any glowing red gem. Several famous historic rubies, including the large red stone in the British Imperial State Crown, turned out to be spinel when they were finally tested.
Garnet has its own long history. Dark red garnets from Bohemia were hugely popular in Victorian jewellery, and garnet signet rings go back to Roman times. It was never a substitute in the eyes of the people who wore it.
The kinds of red garnet
Garnet is a family, and three members supply most red stones.
Pyrope. A pure, dark red, sometimes close to ruby in colour. The classic Bohemian garnet.
Almandine. The most common. Deep red with a brown or violet tint.
Rhodolite. A mix of the two, with a lively purplish or raspberry red. Often the most attractive in a ring.
If you are choosing a garnet, rhodolite and bright pyrope stay red in dim light better than dark almandine.
What about red spinel?
Spinel is the third red stone worth knowing. It is harder than garnet at 8 on the Mohs scale, usually very clean, and a bright red that can rival ruby. It is rarer than garnet and costs more, though still less than ruby. A seller should name it as spinel.
Settings and care
Ruby can go in any setting, including open claw settings, because it resists knocks and scratches. Garnet benefits from a little more protection. A bezel or signet setting keeps its edges from wear and suits its deep colour.
Clean both in warm water with mild soap and a soft cloth. Store garnet apart from harder stones such as ruby, sapphire and diamond, which can scratch it.
Four mistakes buyers make
Judging under shop lights. Spotlights make every red stone glow. Look near a window.
Assuming a clean stone is a better ruby. A dark, clean, inexpensive red stone is more often garnet.
Relying on the ultraviolet test alone. Lab-created rubies glow too.
Thinking garnet is second best. Bought knowingly, it is a handsome stone at a fair price.
Which should you choose?
Choose ruby if
You want a ring to wear every day for decades.
You value rarity and a brighter, purer red.
Your budget allows for a natural stone of good colour.
Choose garnet if
You like a deep, dark red.
You want a larger stone for the money.
The ring is for regular rather than constant wear.
Neither choice is second best. The only mistake is buying one while believing it is the other.
Common questions
Is garnet a cheap ruby?
No. Garnet is a different mineral with its own character. It costs less because it is far more plentiful, not because it is a poor stone.
Can garnet be sold as ruby?
It should not be, but it happens. Old jewellery and unlabelled stones are the usual cases. A dark red stone, very clean, at a low price, described as ruby, deserves a second opinion.
Which is better for a men’s ring?
For daily wear, ruby, because of its hardness. For a bold, dark stone at a sensible price, garnet. Both look right in a heavy silver setting.
Does garnet scratch easily?
Not easily, but it is softer than ruby and will show fine wear over years. Store it apart from harder stones and take it off for manual work.
Are ruby and garnet both birthstones?
Yes. Ruby is the birthstone for July and garnet for January.
Is red spinel better than garnet?
It is harder and brighter, and rarer. It costs more than garnet and less than ruby.
How can I be sure which stone I have?
Ask a jeweller to test it. Ruby and garnet react differently to simple instruments, and the check takes a few minutes.
Find your red stone
Every Gemswears ring is cut and set by hand in our own workshop, in the silver or gold you choose, and delivered free worldwide.